Inflation Eases as Core Prices Post Smallest Gain in Years Core prices logged their lowest increase since April 2021, offering relief to investors and the Fed after a run of data at the start of the year revealed simmering price pressures.
The consumer-price index, a gauge for goods and service costs across the U.S. economy, rose 3.4% in April from a year ago, the Labor Department said Wednesday. Core prices that exclude volatile food and energy items climbed 3.6% annually, the lowest increase since April 2021.
Wednesday’s inflation data should also allow officials at the Fed to breathe more easily because it suggests prices and economic activity aren’t reaccelerating. A separate report Wednesday showed retail sales were flat in April, reaffirming that hypothesis.
“This is a very comforting report,” said Erica Groshen, a senior economic adviser at the Cornell University School of Industrial and Labor Relations. “It is consistent with the view of a soft landing.” (…)
The pressure is off for a few months. Core CPI had been rising quarterly since Q3’23: from 3.0% annualized in Q3, 3.4% in Q4, 4.2% in Q1’24. April’s 3.5% a.r. rate breaks the trend, although the first 4 months clock at 4.2% annualized. Last 3 months: +4.1% a.r., still far from the 2% target.
- Core goods prices fell 0.1%, driven almost entirely by new and used autos (down 0.4% and 1.4%, respectively).
- “Other” core goods prices rose 0.5%, the largest increase since August 2022. On a core or total basis, the slowdown in goods inflation has accounted for the bulk of the decline in inflation since its peak in mid- 2022.
- “Prices for services ex-energy have risen 5.3% over the past year compared to an average annual rate of 2.8% from 2015-2019. The April CPI showed inflation in the service sector easing once again, albeit at a still-painfully-slow pace. Core services prices rose 0.4% in April, returning to its Q4-23 pace. Primary shelter inflation eased somewhat further, with both owners’ equivalent rent and rent of primary residences moderating to a monthly increase of 0.41%.
- Excluding primary shelter, services inflation cooled more materially in April, with the “super core” up 0.4% after a 0.7% gain March. Contributing to the moderation was slower growth for medical services (+0.4%) and motor vehicle insurance and maintenance.” (Wells Fargo)
The Inflation Battle Is Far From Over Services price gains all but rule out rate cuts in the near term. (John Authers)
(…) The problem is that services inflation remains stubbornly high, and accounts for substantially all of headline inflation at this point:
(…) Breaking this down further, the following chart shows inflation for owner’s equivalent rent (a highly contentious measure of shelter cost), and for two measures that were rarely cited before this surge in prices began, but which are now at the center of the debate. One is so-called “supercore” inflation, which measures services excluding shelter, and which the Fed regards as important, and CPI excluding food, shelter, energy and used cars. Most people do need to buy all of these things, but the Bureau of Labor Statistics began printing this number in 2021 at a point when inflationary pressure was concentrated in those items. This is what they look like:
(…) Most disquietingly, supercore is on a continuing rising trend. It’s near 5%, and far above any level with which the central bank can be comfortable. It turned upward last fall (coincidentally or otherwise, when Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell executed his infamous “pivot” toward reducing rates) and its rise continues. Viewed on a month-on-month basis, supercore rose less in April than it had in the three preceding months of the year, but it still looks historically high. This alone more or less rules out a rate cut as early as next month:
(…) That trend is confirmed by the Atlanta Fed’s sticky price index, which concentrates on goods and services whose prices take a while to change and seldom fall. This is seen as inflation that’s particularly difficult to reverse, and so any rise will make the central bank uncomfortable. It is coming down, but very slowly, and it remains above 4%:
Taken together these confirm that disinflation is still happening while there is no sign of an outright acceleration. So rate hikes look very unlikely. But cuts in the near term can also be ruled out as several key measures are sticky and remain too high. (…)
What the Stall in April Retail Sales Says About the Consumer
One theme of this Fed tightening cycle, now entering its third year, is how consumers have been undaunted by higher borrowing costs. Yet, the fact that retail sales stalled in April is not necessarily a sign the consumer is spent; but for once at least it does not show continued evidence of an unstoppable consumer.
Not only did the unchanged headline number come in short of expectations, but the control group aggregation of sales categories gave back 0.3% of last month’s 1.0% gain.
There are reasons to be skeptical of the sustainability of consumer spending beyond today’s retail sales report, such as the depletion of pandemic-era savings and the unsustainability of ever-more consumer credit growth to sustain spending. In short, we see reasons for the consumer to eventually take a breather, but we are not convinced that this soft print is evidence of that exhaustion.
There are more than a few special factors to consider that make today’s report less compelling as evidence of a major consumer pivot. For starters, the timing of Easter was earlier than usual, a dynamic that flatters March data and potentially weighs on April, the month that usually includes that spring holiday and the associated surge in consumer outlays that goes with it.
Another dynamic is online spending reflected in the non-store retailer category. Once a tiny component, consumers now spend more online than they do anywhere else, except when they purchase an automobile. The top-dog in this space, Amazon, hosted its Spring Sales Event in the final week of March. It is not uncommon for other online sellers to offer concurrent discounts. The upshot is many households pulled forward demand, buying a bunch of stuff online in March, so no surprise to see that category down 1.2% in April. (…)
U.S. Department of Commerce, U.S. Department of Labor and Wells Fargo Economics